(Bloomberg) — US Representative Jerrold Nadler beat fellow incumbent Representative Carolyn Maloney in a race that pit the two 30-year congressional veterans against one another for a seat in a redrawn New York district.
Nadler had 56% of the vote with 53% of votes counted as of 9:38 p.m. in New York, according to the Associated Press. Maloney had 24.3% and Suraj Patel had 18.3%, according to the AP, which called the race for Nadler.
The 12th Congressional District matchup on Manhattan’s Upper West Side and Upper East Side featured two powerful committee chairs: Nadler, 75, on the Judiciary Committee and Maloney, 76, on Oversight. Patel is a 38-year-old former aide to President Barack Obama who touted himself as a generational alternative.
“New Yorkers get to choose who best represents the people and values of this city. The voters made themselves clear tonight,” Nadler said in a victory speech at the Arte Cafe on the Upper West Side.
Nadler said he spoke to Maloney and Patel, who he said had both conceded. “Carolyn Maloney and I have spent much of our adult lives working together for the betterment of both New York and and the country,” he said.
Upstate in the Hudson Valley, Representative Sean Patrick Maloney, who is leading the Democratic effort to keep control of the House, trounced progressive state Senator Alessandra Biaggi, by more than 34 percentage points, according to AP.
Biaggi, the granddaughter of former US Representative Mario Biaggi, was endorsed by New York Democratic US Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez.
New York’s congressional primaries are among the most-watched in the country, with a chaotic redistricting battle pushing back the primary and setting up a rare incumbent-versus-incumbent battle.
The late August races in New York and Florida mark the two biggest states left on the 2022 primary calendar going into a midterm election that will decide control of Congress and governor’s offices in 36 states.
It’s been a cycle dominated by intraparty divisions on both sides — Republicans over their loyalty to Trump and Democrats over how far left the party should govern. And it’s been intensified by redrawn political maps that have most members of Congress running in new districts.
Both Nadler and Maloney relied heavily on key constituencies. Nadler campaigned as the last remaining Jewish member of the New York delegation. Maloney’s first campaign ad highlighted her role as a pioneering woman in the House and ended with the tag line “You cannot send a man to do a woman’s job.” Democrats outnumber Republicans by a 7-to-1 margin in the city, and the primary winner will be heavily favored in November.
The race was marked by low turnout in a primary held in the dead of August when many New Yorkers are taking summer vacation. As of 6 p.m., only about 10% of eligible voters had cast ballots, according to the New York City Board of Elections.
“It’s terrible,” said Alice Kane, a lawyer in Manhattan’s Midtown East neighborhood, about the redistricting fracas that delayed the primary date from June to August.
Kane said she voted for Maloney in New York’s 12th Congressional district, but that the choice between the two was a tough one. “I think it’s a shame we had to pit Nadler against her. We had to make a choice. It’s hard.”
Leslie Lewis, 49, a business owner who lives near Lincoln Center in Manhattan said she voted for Patel because of his high-energy and intellect. She said Maloney, Nadler and Patel were all good candidates and that it was “shocking” they all got thrown into the same district. She voted for Patel because he was a “breath of fresh air” compared to Nadler and Maloney, who have served in Congress for three decades.
The winner of New York’s 10th Congressional District remained an open question as of 11:10 p.m. on Tuesday night. With an estimated 93% of votes counted, Levi Strauss & Co. heir Dan Goldman, a former Trump prosecutor, was leading by only about 1,300 votes, according to the AP, which hadn’t called the race.
State Assembly Member Yuh-Line Niou was a close second, followed by Representative Mondaire Jones, who moved from his Hudson Valley district to New York City because of redistricting and faces the prospect of ending his two-year run in the House.
In a surprising move on Tuesday night, Goldman, who ran as a defender of election integrity, stood on stage and declared himself the winner before the race was called or other candidates conceded.
He said he appreciates and respects the Democratic process, but added “it’s quite clear from the way the results have come in that we have won.”
Niou, however, in a separate speech, said she would “not concede until we count every vote. Because what we can do together is too important to give up this fight.”
The city’s Board of Elections will need to sort through absentee and military ballots — and affidavit ballots from voters who tried to cast a ballot on Tuesday but whose eligibility to vote was in question.
There could be as many as 13,600 outstanding absentee ballots that could still be counted if they were postmarked by Tuesday and arrive within seven days, according to the New York City Board of Elections. New York law requires an automatic recount when the margin is within 0.5%. Goldman was leading Tuesday night by 2.1%.
New York also conducted one last election under the old maps, a special election to fill the unexpired term of former Representative Anthony Delgado, who resigned his seat to become lieutenant governor. Democratic Ulster County Executive Pat Ryan defeated Republican Dutchess County Executive Marc Molinaro in a Hudson Valley and Catskills district seen as a key indicator of whether Democrats could hold ground they won in 2020.
Read More: New York’s Redistricting Chaos Creates House Election Intrigue
In Florida, US Representative Charlie Crist — a former Republican — will be the Democratic candidate to challenge incumbent Governor Ron DeSantis in a race that could have implications for the 2024 presidential election.
Crist, who served a term as Florida governor from 2007 to 2011, defeated state agriculture commissioner Nikki Fried in a primary Tuesday to take on DeSantis in November. The incumbent governor has emerged as one of the leading Republican alternatives to former President Donald Trump.
The Associated Press called the Democratic primary shortly after the final polls in the state closed with Crist leading Fried by more than 25 percentage points.
Representative Val Demings handily won a four-way Democratic primary to run against Republican Senator Marco Rubio.
Republican Representative Matt Gaetz, a staunch Trump ally, defeated Marine Corps veteran Mark Lombardo Florida’s 1st Congressional District. Gaetz is under investigation for sex trafficking after sending online payments to a 17-year-old girl who was his travel companion. Gaetz denies the allegations.
In Florida’s 11th District incumbent Republican Representative Daniel Webster defeated far-right activist Laura Loomer 50.7% to 44.5%.
In Oklahoma, the only other state holding elections Tuesday, Representative Markwayne Mullin won a special runoff election to become the Republican nominee for the Senate seat now held by the retiring Jim Inhofe.
Mullin had Trump’s endorsement over former Oklahoma House Speaker T.W. Shannon, and will face former Representative Kendra Horn, a Democrat, in November.